Book Review: An India that can say yes: a climate-responsible development agenda

Review of Praful's recent book on Indian climate policy

27 May 2010
Nagraj Adve

This review of Praful Bidwai's An India that can say yes: a climate responsible agenda for Copenhagen and beyond, considers his critique of Indian climate policy and recommendations for more ambitious action from India to mitigate and adapt to the impacts of climate change, while defending North-South equity.

Download the full review as a .pdf

"Global warming underlines myriad interlinked issues, which play out at different levels. It is a product of the logic of industrial capitalism. It will worsen with the ongoing neoliberal development trajectories that rely hugely on the market.

"It has enriched debates around equity and exposed the limits of nation state frameworks in dealing with global ecological crises that have systemic roots. Given the absence of equity and justice therein, it has exposed the poverty of both the development trajectory and climate policy of major governments. It has already had severe impacts on ecosystems and people in India (and beyond). Feedbacks at merely 0.8 degrees Celcius of average warming do not just exacerbate already existing crises faced by the poor but also highlight the dangers and possibility of runaway, levels of warming, and therein lies its urgency.

"The book under review deals for a good part with the hollowness of India's climate policy, offers rich insights into notions of equity, comments on alternative climate proposals that have been discussed internationally, suggests low-carbon development strategies specifically in the Indian context, and much else. No secondary book on climate change and India can, henceforth, be written satisfactorily without reference to this one."

Recent publications from Environmental Justice

A Landmark Victory for Justice: Biowatch’s Battle with the South African State and Monsanto

Published by  Biowatch South Africa, this is a book about access to information, the right to know, and action in the public’s interest – a must-read for anyone campaigning for environmental or social justice.

Protecting carbon to destroy forests

This paper provides historical background and reports of experiences on the ground to show how land and nature enclosures are central to REDD+, and why it therefore cannot be fixed.

Myth Busting: EU's Emissions Trading System

Since the adoption of the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS), emissions have risen and the price of consumer energy went up along with the profits of many industrial actors.

Accounting for carbon, depoliticising plunder

The EU aspires to global leadership in developing ‘sustainable biofuels’, arguing they can substitute for fossil fuels, but the result has been dispossession of rural communities throughout the South.